Cross post 196
Why wait for climate change when you can just pick off chunks and bring them to a desert -__-
If you look at their current sourcing it’s fine. They’re not cutting apart glaciers, they’re gathering it from parts that have calved and will just melt apart regardless.
Greenland has a right to sell their natural resources as much as anyone else, and the sad thing is this admittedly ludicrous enterprise is more profitable for less environmental damage than most things.
The problem is all the carbon that is emitted to transport the ice from Greenland halfway around the world for no other reason than bullshit marketing.
Yeah but have you considered that this ice is icier than other ice?
Okay now I’m convinced
Ice XIV: lol
I prefer ice ix that comes with the weird foot religion.
I prefer Diet Ice. Tastes like regular ice but without the saturated fats and all that sugar.
Since Greenland Imports a lot and doesn’t really have a lot of export, a big part of the trip would be sailed anyway, just with empty containers
People forget it’s not just the shipping itself. First of all, ships just like every other vehicle need more energy to move the heavier they are. Secondly the ice needs to be cooled for most of the trip and portable coolers are real energy guzzlers. So without doing the maths transporting ice from Greenland to Dubai is much more harmful than ships with empty containers on the same way.
The first point doesn’t hold though. it is always better to have a ship run with cargo than without, in terms of efficiency. Afterall the point of the ship moving is to transport cargo.
For the cooling i am also sceptical. It was common all over Europe to trade with ice cut out of glaciers and frozen lakes until the invention of the cooling pump made electrical fridges a thing. If you store the ice in somewhat well insulated containers, it will cool itself quite decently for long travels. Icecellars were common to hold Ice that was collected in winter and lasted for cooling all throughout the year even in the mediteranian areas.
I also find this business obscene, but i do not see, that it would be more harmful, than sending empty ships around the world.
It is more efficient to have a ship moving with cargo than without, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t additional emissions. The ratio of profit to effort is just higher because there is some profit as opposed to none. You wouldn’t load a ship up with useless mass you can’t sell just so you’re shipping something.
Your argument is like always running the heater in your car because that way the engine heat is at least used for something. Yes, technically the efficiency goes up because more of the energy in the fuel is harnessed. But that doesn’t mean the fuel usage or emissions are any lower, and in the summer the heater doesn’t do you any good either.
I thought it was only possible because they are using ships that would otherwise be empty on their return trips otherwise they couldn’t afford it
International overseas shipping is actually pretty carbon efficient as transport goes.
Hell they’re actually pretty down for efficiency improvements in shipping, to the point where people are just straight up talking about bringing back sails because… Well, why not? It’s free energy.
It’s not necessary but you compare this to crypto or deliberately inefficient vehicle design and it’s just not something to get upset about.
Insert any good where any country doesn’t source it themselves.
deleted by creator
…ice which has never been polluted by any human being.
shows picture of human being polluting said ice
Why is his face so punchable
omg I never noticed that, yea he defo has a face that looks like it would be a punching face in cliche cartoon scenes. I don’t mean it as an insult just an observation lol
Rich people sicken me.
Literally and on purpose, because it’s profitable
Guess I’ll post this again:
I put this in the cross post, bit figure it belongs here, too:
While ridiculous, there’s interesting context here.
- Greenland has little to no economy
- The ice is mined from ice that has already broken away from the glacier, thus not reducing any more than nature has already
- Cargo ships bringing frozen food used to leave empty, now that same fuel is used to transport ice back instead of going to waste
- The founder has always dreamed of a sustainable economy for Greenland
- He is conflicted about how his work to do this in a sustainable way is being taken
Lots of gray here.
The whole conversation, including how the ships are already there, details on economy, etc, are in this thread: https://lemmy.world/comment/6556590
Thanks, that’s an interesting balance.
Greenland has little to no economy because it has a population less than 60 000. And they still have to fly the ice to the middle east from Greenland which is hardly climate friendly.
Cause vs correlation, and untrue. There is no economy because there is only fish. The population dwindles because of immigration. As for flying the ice, that does not happen. Read the link.
Greenland’s per capita GDP is 13th in the world. They’re doing fine. Greenland has also always had a small population. It’s hardly fair to call it dwindling, when it’s about double today what it was in the 60s. Also a large part of the emigration is because the choices for higher education are very limited. Not because of a lack of industry or employment. As there is more than enough mining, fishing and tourism to sustain a population of 57000.
As for shipping the ice, I’m sure you aren’t going to try to tell me that keeping ice refrigerated from nuuk to Dubai as well as the extra fuel used to transport (ships displace more water when they have cargo) have less of a carbon footprint than simply freezing water in Dubai.
Here is an alternative Piped link(s):
Some Greenlandic music for you
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I’m open-source; check me out at GitHub.
This is going to be how the zombie virus comes about. Someone ingests a million year old virus that becomes infectious and boom, we got new COVID.
COVIID
COVID 2: Synaptic Boogaloo
We already had a novel one, so is the next one going to be neo COVID or cyber COVID or what? Or just new COVID, like new Coke?
Vanilla Cov.
deleted by creator
Here is an alternative Piped link(s):
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I’m open-source; check me out at GitHub.
I for one welcome our new puzzle solving robot overlords.
Mmmm it’s like playing the lottery but if you win you get to be patient zero for the ancient virus that ends up wiping out humanity.
That’s why I only drink 151 on the rocks.
Gimme that ✨prehistoric bacteria✨
It’s environmentally friendly because they don’t waste energy to freeze the water. It’s already frozen! /s
So while the rest of us are worrying about shrinking glaciers, Dubai is actively ice mining glaciers and shipping them to the middle of the desert so rich people can have fancy cocktails. Out-fucking-standing.
No, this is exported by Greenland.
They’re using only chunks that have already separated, transporting it on outgoing cargo ships that are already empty and it becomes one of the few export products for Greenland.
Weird idea, but there are a few redeeming points if you look at the full story.
Okay, that’s a lot less troubling than I expected. Thanks for the clarification.
I’m cool with it in that state. But my concern here is that while it starts out innocent, if demand increases, it’s only a matter of time until they start mining it and chartering more ships to transport it. Especially in an economy like Greenland’s.
This same pattern has been followed a thousand times in the past. Lots of instances of abusing our natural resources start out innocently.
It’s okay, I can only imagine the 10,000 year old bacteria those guys are gonna be drinking with that ice when it thaws, it all balances out.
*100,000 year old bacteria. It’s never infected any human being!
Little bit of salt and lemon sounds nice with it
“Yeah our ice is mined in… uh… Greenland. That will be $200”
“Dumbass”
Had to ask myself what kind of bars they even had on Dubai. Apparently they don’t take the alcohol thing as seriously as I thought.
It’s Dubai bro…
“Yeah, I’m still drinking what used to be piss, but at least it wasn’t human piss. Because ewwies. Right, barkeep?”
Barkeep: (two thumbs up) (how the fuck should I know)
Also barkeep: Looks behind and realises they can’t remember which box is the expensive ice.
Also also barkeep: Remembers they froze some of their piss earlier and lost track of it.
They must keep really hydrated!
well, glacial ice turns to ice ii, which is denser and bluer…
My bar serves water wayyy older than that.
So this is how the Arctic plague begins
